Data Center Lawsuit
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |

San Antonio Data Center Lawsuit Won’t Pay Neighbors. Texas Nuisance Law Might.

The San Antonio Data Center Lawsuit Won’t Pay the Neighbors. Texas Nuisance Law Might.

What the Vantage and VoltaGrid Clean Air Act Case Means for Texas Landowners Living Next to a Data Center Power Plant

On September 21, 2026, two national environmental groups sued the companies behind two data center campuses on San Antonio’s far West Side. Each campus runs its own natural gas power plant and a yard full of diesel generators. The headlines are about air permits. If you live near one of those campuses, or near any data center that makes its own power, the headline you need is a different one.

Here is the short version before the analysis. That lawsuit is not your lawsuit, and it will not pay you anything. If the plant next door is keeping you up at night, your rights come from Texas nuisance law, and the clock on those rights may already be running.

Quick Answers

What is the San Antonio data center lawsuit? A federal Clean Air Act citizen suit, Public Citizen and Sierra Club v. Vantage Data Centers Management Company, LLC, et al., No. 5:26-cv-06032, in the Western District of Texas. It alleges that Vantage and VoltaGrid split each campus into “minor” pollution sources to avoid major-source permits and public hearings. Those are allegations. No court has decided them.

Will the lawsuit compensate the neighbors? No. It asks for permits, an injunction, mitigation, and civil penalties paid into a federal fund. No neighbor recovers lost value or lost sleep from it.

What rights does a neighbor have? Texas private nuisance law. If a condition substantially interferes with the use and enjoyment of your land and would bother a person of ordinary sensibilities, you can sue for damages, an injunction, or in some cases both.

Does a state permit protect the operator from a nuisance claim? No. A permit is not a defense to a private nuisance.

How long do I have? Generally two years. Since June 2026, the Supreme Court of Texas has held that once that deadline runs, it bars a request for an injunction as well as damages.

What should I do first? Start a dated log of what you hear, see, and smell, and when. These cases are won with records, not adjectives.

What the lawsuit actually claims

The plaintiffs are Public Citizen and the Sierra Club, represented by the Environmental Integrity Project. The defendants are Vantage Data Centers Management Company, LLC; Vantage Data Centers TX11, LLC; Vantage Data Centers TX21, LLC; and VoltaGrid LLC. The case is pending in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas, San Antonio Division. The 51-page complaint is public.

How the lawsuit got here

The suit did not come out of nowhere. The Clean Air Act requires a citizen group to give 60 days’ notice before it sues. On July 22, 2026, the Sierra Club and Public Citizen sent a notice of intent to sue to the three Vantage entities and VoltaGrid, with copies to the EPA, the TCEQ, and Governor Abbott. Texas Public Radio and Inside Climate News covered the notice at the time.

The notice is worth reading if you live in the area. It states that the campuses sit near residential neighborhoods, medical offices, hospitals, parks, retirement homes, schools, daycares, and churches. According to the groups, the companies did not resolve the alleged violations during the notice period, and the complaint was filed on September 21, the day after that period ended.

The complaint concerns two campuses in Bexar County: 14270 Omicron Drive and 5207 Rogers Road. According to the plaintiffs, each campus has a dedicated natural gas power plant that serves only the data center, about 405 megawatts combined, plus 151 diesel backup generators capable of roughly 455 more. The July notice put the gas generation at 423 megawatts; the complaint uses the lower figure.

The core allegation is that the companies registered the power plants and the generators separately, each as a “minor” source under Texas Commission on Environmental Quality standard permits and permits by rule, which require no public notice, comment, or hearing. The plaintiffs say each campus is really one integrated major source that needed a full federal permit before construction began. The notice and the complaint also allege that the Rogers Road campus ran its diesel backup generators as its primary power source before its gas plant was finished. The notice places that in 2025.

These are allegations, not findings. The defendants have not been found liable for anything.

So there is no confusion about what I do: I do not handle air permits, and this guide will not predict whether the plaintiffs win their Clean Air Act case. My work is on the landowner’s side of the fence, and that is what the rest of this guide is about.

This lawsuit will not pay the people next door

The case is brought under the Clean Air Act’s citizen-suit provision, 42 U.S.C. Section 7604. That statute lets private groups enforce federal air law. It does not give anyone damages.

The prayer for relief asks for declarations, an injunction against construction and operation until major-source permits are obtained, an order against running the Rogers Road generators as primary power, mitigation, civil penalties, and attorney’s fees. The complaint itself says the penalties are payable to a fund in the U.S. Treasury that pays for air enforcement.

The plaintiffs plead that their members who live nearby have lost the use and enjoyment of their homes. That is how they establish standing to sue. But even if the plaintiffs win everything they ask for, no neighbor’s lost sleep is compensated and no neighbor’s property value is restored. And a fully permitted power plant can still be a nuisance to the house across the road.

Practice Insight
Nothing about a lawsuit filed by someone else stops your own two-year clock. Waiting to see how the federal case turns out is one of the most expensive mistakes a neighbor can make.

Texas courts have seen gas engines next door before

According to the complaint, VoltaGrid registered 80 natural gas engines for the Omicron Drive plant and 36 for the Rogers Road plant. Texas has a long history with neighbors of gas engines. Two of the Supreme Court of Texas‘s most important modern nuisance decisions involved natural gas compressor stations: Crosstex North Texas Pipeline, L.P. v. Gardiner, 505 S.W.3d 580 (Tex. 2016), and Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America v. Justiss, 397 S.W.3d 150 (Tex. 2012).

Under Texas law, a private nuisance is a condition that substantially interferes with the use and enjoyment of land by causing unreasonable discomfort or annoyance to persons of ordinary sensibilities attempting to use and enjoy it. The Court has said that noise, odors, dust, and bright lights can qualify when they are sufficiently extreme. Schneider National Carriers, Inc. v. Bates, 147 S.W.3d 264, 269 (Tex. 2004).

I walk through how Texas courts apply that standard to a constant hum and to light that crosses the fence in Guide 4, What if Data Center Lights or Noise Are Driving Me Crazy? The short version is that nothing is automatic. The interference has to be substantial, and it is judged by an ordinary person, not by the most sensitive neighbor.

Does a permit protect the data center from a nuisance claim?

No. Data center operators will point to their permits, and a permit is not a defense to a private nuisance. In Huynh v. Blanchard, No. 21-0676 (Tex. June 7, 2024), the Supreme Court of Texas cited authority holding that a permit does not foreclose common-law nuisance liability. It also held that the agency’s enforcement powers were not a substitute for the neighbors’ own remedy in court.

The Court relied in part on Texas Water Code Section 7.004, which preserves a private person’s common-law remedies to abate a nuisance or recover damages. Compliance with a permit is a fact in the mix. It is not the end of the case.

The hum at the public hearing is the fact that matters

According to San Antonio Current reporting, the Rogers Road campus was already partly operational before Vantage and the TCEQ held a public hearing on it earlier this year. At the hearing, neighbors said the constant hum kept them from sleeping. Others asked how often the diesel generators would really run, and what counts as an emergency. The notice of intent describes a May 28, 2026 public hearing at which, it says, Vantage represented that its backup generators were already partially operational.

Those are not Clean Air Act facts. They are nuisance facts, the kind I cover in Guide 2, Texas Landowner’s Guide to Living Next to a Data Center. But a statement at a public hearing is not a case. A nuisance claim is won with proof that the interference is substantial, recurring, and unreasonable to an ordinary person, and that proof has to be gathered while it is happening.

In Huynh, the neighbors of two poultry farms logged 330 odor events, complained to the TCEQ repeatedly, and used an expert who matched their logs against wind data from a nearby weather station. That record is why they won an injunction.

Your two-year clock may already be running

A private nuisance claim in Texas carries a two-year statute of limitations under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.003. When the clock starts depends on whether the nuisance is permanent or temporary, a distinction I explain in Is Injury to Your Land Permanent or Temporary? It Matters Greatly!. For a permanent nuisance, the claim generally accrues when the injury first occurs or is discovered. A temporary nuisance gives rise to a new claim with each injury, but recovery reaches back only two years before suit.

Until this summer, many Texas courts said that limitations could never bar a suit simply to stop a nuisance. That is no longer the law. In Family Dollar Stores of Texas, LLC v. JLMH Investments, LLC, No. 24-0543 (Tex. June 26, 2026), the Supreme Court of Texas held that the two-year statute bars a request for an injunction the same way it bars the damages claim. There is no free-standing right to abate a nuisance after the deadline has passed.

I covered that decision in Guide 3, What Happens When Data Center Construction Floods My Land?, because Family Dollar was itself a drainage case. The rule applies the same way to noise and light. Apply it to a campus whose backup generators, according to the notice, Vantage itself described as partially operational by May 2026: if the hum started when the equipment came online, a neighbor who waits on the federal case may find the state-law deadline has already passed.

Practice Insight
Whether a nuisance is permanent or temporary is often the most contested question in the case, because it decides both the deadline and the measure of damages. In Justiss, the jury tied the start of the nuisance to the date the TCEQ issued a citation. The paper trail you build now can decide when your clock started.
Living next to a data center power plant in Bexar, Medina, Comal, Guadalupe, or Atascosa County? Do not wait on someone else’s lawsuit to protect your own rights.
Call 210-354-7600 to talk with a Texas lawyer who represents landowners, by video or in person.
Representing Texas Land Owners. Not Data Center Developers.

What the Huynh poultry case tells data center neighbors

Huynh is a poultry case, but it reads as if it were written for this one. Neighbors in Henderson County sued over two chicken farms on a single 230-acre tract. The record showed that the growers told state regulators the property held two separate farms controlled by two different LLCs, even though the farms sat side by side and ran as a single operation. The poultry company’s own internal memo said the barns needed to be considered as one unit. The growers also told regulators there were no neighbors within a quarter mile.

Splitting one operation into paper entities to stay under a regulatory threshold is, in Clean Air Act terms, what the San Antonio complaint alleges. Whether that allegation is proven is for the federal court. The point for a landowner is that the same pattern has already played out in a Texas nuisance case.

Here is what the Supreme Court of Texas held:

  • An injunction was proper. The neighbors had no adequate remedy at law because the nuisance kept recurring and would have required suit after suit.
  • TCEQ enforcement was not an adequate substitute. Neighbors called the agency and waited hours for investigators while the wind changed.
  • A total shutdown, ordered as the first remedy, was an abuse of discretion. An injunction may go no further than needed to bring the conditions below nuisance level, and the case went back to the trial court to narrow it.

The lesson for a data center neighbor is practical. The realistic remedy is usually targeted relief, such as operating limits, enclosures, or other measures that bring noise or light below a nuisance level, rather than closing a campus. And you will be expected to prove what level is a nuisance.

Can I recover for lost property value?

Possibly, but you have to prove it. In Justiss, homeowners near a noisy compressor station testified that their property values had dropped and won a jury verdict. The Supreme Court of Texas held that testimony legally insufficient. An owner can testify to the value of his own property, but not by simply naming a number. The owner must give the factual basis for the opinion, such as comparable sales. 397 S.W.3d at 159.

You also generally cannot have it both ways. A court will not award damages for permanent future loss of value and also an injunction that stops the future harm, because that is a double recovery. Which remedy to pursue is a strategic choice that should be made early.

Guide 6, Will a Data Center Next Door Lower My Property Value?, explains what evidence of lost value holds up and how to start building it.

What the complaint teaches about reading any data center project

Set the Clean Air Act aside, and the complaint is still a useful case study in how a large project can look smaller on paper than it is. These allegations are worth knowing whether you live in Westover Hills or out in Medina County.

  • The land tells you what is coming. The complaint alleges both tracts were bought substantially larger than the first buildings described to regulators. If a buyer is approaching you, read Guide 1, Texas Landowner’s Guide to Selling Property for a Data Center.
  • Find out who actually holds title. The landowning LLCs were renamed in October 2023, from TX1 and TX2 to TX11 and TX21. Check the county deed records, such as Bexar County’s real property records, before you send a demand letter or file suit.
  • Track the revisions, not just the first filing. Generator counts were revised upward, from 22 to 86 at Omicron Drive and from 33 to 65 at Rogers Road.
  • The project keeps changing. A June 2026 revision added diesel “black start” units to the Omicron Drive plant.
  • Public records show what a plant is actually doing. The notice’s claim that the Rogers Road generators ran as primary power rests in part on Vantage’s own report to the TCEQ of about 22 tons of nitrogen oxide emissions from Rogers Road in 2025. Agency filings are public, and they can show activity a neighbor cannot see from the road.
  • You may not get advance notice. The permit types used required no public notice or hearing. Watch the site and the agency records yourself.

I have written separately about what filings a Texas data center is actually required to make and how governmental approvals affect data center litigation.

Start building your record now

Nuisance cases are won on evidence gathered while the problem is happening, not on a description given two years later. If a data center power plant is interfering with your property, start today.

  1. Keep a dated log. Every time the noise, light, or odor interferes, write down the date, the time, how long it lasted, and what it kept you from doing. Sleep interruptions matter, so record those.
  2. Record it. Dated video at night, with the sound audible and the time visible. Note the wind direction when you can.
  3. Complain in writing. Send complaints to the operator and file them with the TCEQ, and keep copies. Agency records become evidence.
  4. Write down when it started. The date the conditions first began may control your deadline.
  5. Pull your deed and survey. You will need to show exactly where your property sits relative to the plant.
  6. Do not sign anything first. Have a lawyer read any “good neighbor” agreement, release, or offer from the operator before you sign it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I join the Sierra Club lawsuit to recover my own damages?

No. It is a Clean Air Act citizen suit, and that statute does not provide damages to individuals. A neighbor’s claims for lost use and enjoyment or lost value arise under Texas nuisance law and have to be brought on their own.

If a data center has a TCEQ permit, can it still be a nuisance?

Yes. Texas courts have held that a permit does not foreclose common-law nuisance liability, and Texas Water Code Section 7.004 preserves a private person’s remedies. The question is whether the conditions substantially and unreasonably interfere with the use of your property.

Can a court shut down a data center because of noise?

It is possible but unlikely as a first step. Under Huynh v. Blanchard, an injunction can go no further than needed to bring conditions below nuisance level. Targeted limits are the more realistic outcome.

How long do I have to file a nuisance claim in Texas?

Generally two years. When the clock starts depends on whether the nuisance is permanent or temporary. Since June 2026, missing the deadline bars an injunction as well as damages.

Can I just testify that my house lost value?

You can testify to your own property’s value, but the testimony must rest on a factual basis such as comparable sales. In Natural Gas Pipeline Co. of America v. Justiss, owners’ unsupported value opinions were held legally insufficient.

What evidence should I keep if a data center is bothering me?

A dated log of the conditions and their effect on your use of the property, video with timestamps, written complaints to the operator and the TCEQ, and the date the conditions first began.

What this means for South Central Texas landowners

The Vantage and VoltaGrid case will be decided on Clean Air Act issues in federal court. However it comes out, it will not decide whether the plant next door is a nuisance to you, and it will not pay you for what you have lost.

The Vantage campuses show that some data centers will bring their own power plants with them. They are not alone: a July 2026 Environmental Integrity Project report counted at least 74 of these “behind-the-meter” plants nationally. If you own land in Bexar, Medina, Comal, Guadalupe, or Atascosa County and a data center is going up near you, the questions that matter are the ones in this series: what the project really is, what it is doing to your land, and how much time you have to act.

The full Texas Landowner Data Center Guide series:

All of my data center resources are collected on my Texas data center landowner attorney page.

A federal lawsuit about air permits will not protect your property. If a data center is changing how you live on your land, find out what your claims are worth and how much time you have left.
Call 210-354-7600 to talk with a Texas lawyer who represents landowners, by video or in person.
Representing Texas Land Owners. Not Data Center Developers.

Trey Wilson
San Antonio Real Estate Attorney
Texas Water Lawyer

Trey Wilson is a San Antonio real estate and water lawyer with more than 27 years of litigation experience representing Texas landowners in nuisance, property damage, drainage, and land use disputes. He represents landowners, not data center developers, across Bexar, Medina, Comal, Guadalupe, and Atascosa Counties. Learn more at SanAntonioRealEstateLawyer.com or call 210-354-7600.

This guide discusses allegations in a pending federal lawsuit that have not been proven or decided, and general information about Texas law. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every property and every set of facts is different. Talk with a qualified Texas lawyer about your specific situation.